The Masonic Compromise of Conservative Politics and the Betrayal of Catholic Truth
Catholic News Agency portal reports (November 17, 2025) that Princeton professor Robert George resigned from the Heritage Foundation board following its president Kevin Roberts’ initial defense of Tucker Carlson’s interview with antisemitic commentator Nick Fuentes. The article details Roberts’ apology for using the term “venomous coalition” after critics called it antisemitic, while George justified his resignation by appealing to the Declaration of Independence’s language about human equality. Peter Wolfgang of the Family Institute of Connecticut criticized George’s resignation as abandoning Heritage to “the ancient evil” of antisemitism during its repentance attempt. The report frames the controversy through secular political lenses, ignoring the supernatural duties of Catholics toward both Jews and heretics.
Reduction of the Church’s Mission to Naturalistic Humanism
The entire controversy operates within naturalistic parameters (ratione naturali) foreign to Catholic theology. George’s appeal to the Declaration of Independence’s “unalienable rights” replaces the Church’s divine mandate with Enlightenment deism, directly contradicting Pope Pius IX’s condemnation that “human reason…is the sole arbiter of truth” (Syllabus of Errors, Proposition 15). Neither George nor his critics reference the Church’s infallible teaching that “the Jewish people must not be presented as rejected or accursed by God” (Council of Trent, Session IV) nor the parallel duty to combat formal heresy embodied by Fuentes’ racialist ideology.
Roberts’ claim that “Christians can critique the state of Israel without being antisemitic” contains a dangerous half-truth. While legitimate geopolitical criticism is permissible, the article omits the Church’s perennial teaching that “the Jews are under a curse until they turn to Christ” (St. Augustine, City of God XVIII, 46). This silence exemplifies the conciliar sect’s embrace of religious indifferentism condemned by Pope Pius XI: “That false opinion which considers all religions to be more or less good and praiseworthy…is entirely foreign to the Catholic Church” (Mortalium Animos).
The Masonic Subversion of Political Discourse
The report’s focus on “antisemitism” as the supreme evil exposes its ideological captivity to Masonic paradigms. Pope Leo XIII warned that Freemasonry seeks to “destroy the foundations of religion and civil society” (Humanum Genus), precisely by substituting tribal identity politics for supernatural faith. Fuentes’ racial theories and George’s Enlightenment individualism represent two Masonic heresies: the former reflects the occult nationalism of irregular lodges, the latter the deistic universalism of Grand Orient ideology.
Roberts’ original defense of Carlson’s interview as mere “debate” reveals the Luciferian inversion of Catholic epistemology. The Church commands: “Away with all attempts to employ a false prudence by which we would hide the doctrine of Christ!… The principle of religious liberty is contrary to divine revelation” (Pope Pius IX, Quanta Cura). Contrast this with Roberts’ claim that Heritage must avoid “canceling” heretics – a modernist error explicitly condemned: “It is not lawful to demand, defend, or grant unconditional freedom of thought, speech, writing, or religion” (Syllabus of Errors, Proposition 79).
Abandonment of Catholic Christological Kingship
The entire controversy occurs within a Christological vacuum. Neither George’s resignation letter nor the Heritage Foundation’s response mentions Our Lord’s social reign, despite Quas Primas mandating that “rulers of states…publicly honor and obey to the reigning Christ.” This omission proves the conservative movement’s fundamental apostasy from Catholic order.
Peter Wolfgang’s lament that George resigned when Heritage “needs support of the adults in the room” demonstrates the bankruptcy of “cultural Catholicism.” True Catholic adults would echo Pope St. Pius X: “The duty of the Church…is to proclaim that there is no true civilization without a moral civilization, and no true moral civilization without the true religion” (Notre Charge Apostolique). Instead, Wolfgang reduces the Faith to a tribal marker in the “neocon vs MAGA” squabble – a betrayal of the Church’s universal mission.
The article’s concluding reference to “Pope Leo XIV” condemning antisemitism completes this diabolical parody. The conciliar antipopes have no authority to teach, yet the report treats this usurper’s words as magisterial. True Catholics recall Pope Pius XI’s warning: “Any religious movement which opposes the Divine Church is working not only against God, but against civilization itself” (Divini Redemptoris). Until conservatives reject the Masonic lie of religious neutrality and embrace the Social Reign of Christ the King, their projects will remain vessels of error.
Source:
Robert George resigns from Heritage Foundation board over Kevin Roberts video (catholicnewsagency.com)
Date: 17.11.2025