The National Register portal reports on the renewed relevance of Ida Friederike Görres’ book *Bread Grows in Winter*, a collection of essays written between 1967 and 1971. The article, based on an interview with philosopher Hanna-Barbara Gerl-Falkovitz, presents Görres as a prophetic figure who foresaw the crisis of the post-conciliar Church. However, this analysis completely ignores the true nature of the crisis: it is not a cyclical “decay” but a systematic, deliberate destruction of the faith from within, orchestrated by the very authorities the article implicitly legitimizes. The book’s central metaphor of the Church as a “Phoenix” that perpetually rises from its ashes is a modernist trope that obscures the fact that the true Church of Christ, being indefectible, cannot be destroyed; what is “burning” is the conciliar sect, a structure built on the ruins of the Catholic faith.

---

The Myth of the “Phoenix Church”: A Modernist Heresy Disguised as Hope</h1

---

Source:
How the Post-Conciliar Classic ‘Bread Grows in Winter’ Speaks to Our Time   (ncregister.com)
Date: 22.06.2026