Conciliar Hierarchy Begs EU to Spare Baptismal Registers: Ecclesiastical Liberty Extinguished

The National Catholic Register portal (November 21, 2026) reports that the Commission of the Episcopal Conferences of the European Union (COMECE) has issued a position paper pleading with the Court of Justice of the European Union to protect baptismal registers from deletion requests under the GDPR “right to be forgotten.” The trigger was an opinion by Advocate General Laila Medina supporting a Belgian apostate’s demand that the Diocese of Ghent erase his baptismal entry. COMECE argues that baptismal records document a past sacramental event rather than current belief, that the “individual dimension of religious freedom” must be balanced with the “collective and institutional dimensions,” and that altering registers would disrupt the entire sacramental economy. The bishops urge the EU court not to interpret canonical norms in isolation and express trust that the Court will “establish criteria to ensure that these records are protected from deletion, and that the balance between church and state will be maintained.” This groveling before a secular tribunal manifests the total subjection of the conciliar sect to the anti-Christian world order, a betrayal of the Kingship of Christ and the immutable rights of the Church.


The Factual Level: A Simulated Hierarchy Negotiating Its Own Servitude

The reported facts reveal a scandalous inversion of the divine constitution of the Church. The so-called “bishops” of COMECE — a bureaucratic organ of the conciliar sect, devoid of any canonical mission from the true Roman Pontiff — act not as successors of the Apostles invested with potestas ordinaria et immediata (ordinary and immediate power) over the faithful, but as lobbyists petitioning a Masonic-inspired supranational entity (the EU) for permission to keep their own sacramental archives. The very premise of the “case” — a baptized Catholic demanding the erasure of the indelible character of Baptism (character indelebilis) via secular law — is a diabolical mockery of the sacramental order. That the conciliar hierarchy responds not with anathematizing this sacrilege (cf. Council of Trent, Sess. VII, Can. 9 on Baptism) but with a legal position paper drafted by a “legal affairs commission” proves that they have abandoned the supernatural for the juridical, the divine for the human, the rights of God for the “rights of man.”

The article notes the Advocate General’s opinion favors the apostate. This is the inevitable fruit of the false principle of religious liberty condemned by Pius IX in the Syllabus Errorum (Prop. 15: “Every man is free to embrace and profess that religion which, guided by the light of reason, he shall consider true”) and by Leo XIII in Libertas Praestantissimum. The conciliar sect, having embraced this condemned error at Vatican II (Dignitatis Humanae), now reaps its logical harvest: the secular power claims jurisdiction over the very sacra of the Church. As Pius XI teaches in Quas Primas: “When God and Jesus Christ… were removed from laws and states and when authority was derived not from God but from men, the foundations of that authority were destroyed… the entire human society had to be shaken, because it lacked a stable and strong foundation.” The COMECE bishops, by accepting the EU’s competence to adjudicate this matter, consecrate the usurpation of Christ’s Kingship by Caesar.

The Linguistic Level: The Vocabulary of Capitulation and Naturalism

The rhetoric of the COMECE document is saturated with modernist, personalist, and liberal categories that betray a total loss of the sensus catholicus. Consider the phrases deployed:

  • “Individual dimension of religious freedom must be placed on an equal footing with the collective and institutional dimensions” — This is the language of Dignitatis Humanae, not of the Syllabus. It elevates the subjective conscience of the apostate to parity with the ius divinum of the Church. It implies that the Church’s right to her archives is a mere “institutional dimension” of a generic “religious freedom,” rather than a divine mandate flowing from the commission of Christ: “Going therefore, teach ye all nations; baptizing them…” (Mt 28:19).
  • “The ruling gives disproportionate weight to the lack of consent from the baptized person” — Consent? The validity of infant Baptism does not depend on the consent of the infant, nor can the subject later revoke the character by withdrawing consent. This language concedes the modernist premise that the sacraments are human acts dependent on ongoing subjective ratification, a heresy condemned in Lamentabili Sane Exitu (Prop. 41: “The sacraments merely serve to remind man of the presence of the ever-benevolent Creator”).
  • “Retention of this data is necessary for the life of the Church” — A utilitarian, functionalist justification. The registers are kept not because they testify to an ontological, indelible reality wrought by God (character indelebilis), but because they are “necessary for the functioning of the entire sacramental life” — a bureaucratic convenience. “The sacraments arose as a result of the interpretation by the Apostles… under the influence of circumstances” (Lamentabili, Prop. 40) — this modernist evolutionism undergirds the COMECE argument.
  • “Balance between church and state” — The classic Gallican/Erastian formula, condemned by Pius IX (Syllabus, Prop. 55: “The Church ought to be separated from the State, and the State from the Church” — condemned as error, meaning the Church must not be separated in the sense of subordination; but the modernist “balance” means subjection of the Church to the State). Quas Primas declares: “The state must leave the same freedom to the members of Orders… The annual celebration of this solemnity will also remind states that not only private individuals, but also rulers and governments have the duty to publicly honor Christ and obey Him.” There is no “balance”; there is hierarchy: Christ above Caesar.

The Theological Level: Apostasy from the Rights of the Church and the Nature of the Sacraments

1. The Indelible Character vs. The “Right to be Forgotten”
The Council of Trent defines infallibly: “If anyone says that in three sacraments… Baptism, Confirmation, and Order… a character is not imprinted in the soul… let him be anathema” (Sess. VII, Can. 9). This character is a spiritual seal, indelible, configuring the soul to Christ the High Priest. It cannot be erased by any human power, not by the baptized person, not by the bishop, not by the Pope, and certainly not by a secular court. The baptismal register is the authentic instrumental witness to this divine act. To allow its erasure is to deny the reality of the character, to treat the sacrament as a mere human record subject to human revision. This is the heresy of the “sacraments as mere signs” (Lamentabili, Props. 41, 44, 47). The COMECE bishops, by arguing pragmatically (“necessary for sacramental life”) rather than dogmatically (“testifies to an indelible divine seal”), surrender the very ontology of the sacrament.

2. The Jurisdiction of the Church vs. The Competence of the Secular Tribunal
The Syllabus condemns: “The ecclesiastical power ought not to exercise its authority without the permission and assent of the civil government” (Prop. 20); “In the case of conflicting laws enacted by the two powers, the civil law prevails” (Prop. 42); “The civil authority may interfere in matters relating to religion, morality and spiritual government” (Prop. 44). By submitting a “position paper” to the EU Court, COMECE implicitly recognizes the Court’s competence to judge the Church’s canonical legislation. They “urge European courts to avoid interpreting canonical norms in isolation” — as if the Church’s canons require the secular judge’s hermeneutical approval! This is the total reversal of the medieval and Tridentine order, where the Church judged the State in spiritual matters (Gelasian Dyarchy: “Two powers… govern this world: the sacred authority of priests and the royal power” — Pope Gelasius I, Ep. 12). Quas Primas reiterates: “The Church… demands for itself by a right belonging to it, which it cannot renounce, full freedom and independence from secular authority.” COMECE renounces this right in actu exercito.

3. The Invalidity of the Conciliar “Baptism” and “Hierarchy”
From the sedevacantist perspective, the critique goes deeper. The “baptismal records” in question almost certainly document the new rite of Baptism (1969), which is doubtful in form and matter (omission of explicit exorcisms, ambiguous formula, lay administration permitted). The “bishops” of COMECE are either invalidly consecrated (Paul VI’s 1968 rite of episcopal consecration, deficient in form and intention) or manifest heretics who have ipso facto lost all jurisdiction (St. Robert Bellarmine, De Romano Pontifice; Wernz-Vidal, Ius Canonicum; Canon 188.4, 1917 Code; Pope Paul IV, Cum ex Apostolatus Officio). As the Defense of Sedevacantism file demonstrates: “A manifest heretic cannot be Pope or a member of the Church… a non-Christian in no way can be Pope.” The conciliar “bishops,” adhering to the heresies of Vatican II (religious liberty, ecumenism, collegiality, new mass), are outside the Church. Their “baptismal registers” are the archives of a false sect, not the Ecclesia Catholica. The true Church — the remnant of bishops and priests retaining valid orders and the true faith — keeps her own registers in the catacombs, answerable only to Christ the King, not to the EU.

The Symptomatic Level: The Conciliar Sect as the “Abomination of Desolation” in the Holy Place

This episode is not an isolated legal skirmish; it is the public manifestation of the conciliar sect’s nature. The False Fatima Apparitions file identifies the post-conciliar operation as a “Masonic psychological operation against the Church”, with stages of “globalization of the cult,” “control of the narrative,” and “ecumenical reinterpretation.” COMECE is the political arm of this operation in Europe, a paramasonic structure designed to harmonize the “Church” with the European Masonic project (the EU). Its “position paper” is the theological equivalent of the Appellatio ab abusu condemned by Pius IX (Syllabus, Prop. 41) — an appeal to the secular power against the Church’s own liberty.

The silence on the supernatural is deafening. No mention of:

  • The character indelebilis as a divine property, not a data point.
  • The obligation of the bishop to defend the iura Dei even unto death (“The good shepherd giveth his life for his sheep”, Jn 10:11).
  • The final judgment where the apostate and the complicit bishop will answer for the profanation of the sacrament.
  • The Kingship of Christ over the Belgian state, the EU, and the Diocese of Ghent.

Instead, we hear the bureaucratic whine of a NGO seeking “criteria” from a secular court. This is the Church of the New Advent: a humanitarian NGO with sacramental veneer, fully integrated into the antichristic world system. As Pius XI warned in Quas Primas: “The state is happy not by one means, and man by another; for the state is nothing else than a harmonious association of men… Let rulers of states therefore not refuse public veneration and obedience to the reigning Christ.” The COMECE bishops, by their action, counsel the rulers to refuse — they teach the EU that the Church is a subordinate partner begging for “balance.”

Conclusion
The COMECE “position paper” is a document of infamy. It proves that the conciliar hierarchy has no faith in the power of the keys, no confidence in the promises of Christ, no willingness to suffer for the rights of the Church. They have chosen the city of man over the City of God, the GDPR over the Divine Law, the “right to be forgotten” over the indelible seal of the Holy Ghost. “He who is not with me, is against me: and he that gathereth not with me, scattereth” (Mt 12:30). The true bishops of the Catholic Church — those few who remain faithful to the Tradition of 1958, retaining valid orders and jurisdiction supplied by the Church in necessity (Ecclesia supplet) — reject this servility. They keep their registers in secret, they administer the true sacraments, they teach the Kingship of Christ, and they await the restoration of all things in Christ, Instaurare omnia in Christo, when the usurpers in the Vatican and their COMECE lackeys will be cast down, and the liberty of the Church will be vindicated not by EU courts, but by the King of Kings Himself.


Source:
European Bishops Reiterate That Baptismal Records Should Be Protected From Erasure
  (ncregister.com)
Date: 21.11.2026