UN Gaza Resolution Promotes Godless Peace Over Christ’s Reign
Vatican News reports on the proposed UN Security Council resolution endorsing former US President Donald Trump’s Gaza peace plan, which includes an International Stabilization Force and transitional governance. The article notes Israel’s opposition to Palestinian statehood provisions and mentions casualty figures of 69,000 Palestinians and 1,200 Israelis since the 2023 Hamas attack. Egyptian and Russian diplomats reportedly discussed the US-backed draft, with Washington warning that rejection could reignite hostilities.
Naturalistic Peacebuilding Denies Divine Order
The proposed resolution epitomizes the naturalistic fallacy condemned in Pius IX’s Syllabus of Errors (1864), which rejects the notion that “human reason… is the sole arbiter of truth and falsehood” (Proposition 3). By framing peace as a geopolitical arrangement between warring factions rather than submission to Christ the King, the plan ignores Pius XI’s teaching that “nations will be happy and prosperous only when they recognize the reign of our Savior” (Quas Primas, 1925).
The article’s reference to “newly trained Palestinian police” operating outside Hamas fails to acknowledge that no earthly authority can establish lasting peace without recognizing God’s law. As St. Augustine demonstrates in De Civitate Dei, temporal peace divorced from the Eternal Law inevitably degenerates into new conflicts.
Conciliar Sect Complicit in Anti-Christian Diplomacy
Vatican News’ uncritical reporting on this resolution exposes the conciliar sect’s betrayal of Catholic mission. The article treats Qatar – a nation criminalizing Christian evangelization – as a legitimate peace broker, directly contradicting Pius IX’s condemnation of indifferentism: “It is false that the civil liberty of every form of worship… does not conduce to corrupt the morals of the people” (Syllabus of Errors, Proposition 79).
Nowhere does the article mention:
- The duty of Catholic states to defend persecuted Christians in Gaza
- The blasphemous denial of Christ’s universal kingship implicit in UN governance
- The canonical penalty of excommunication for politicians enabling Islamic terrorism (1917 CIC 2334)
Casualty Statistics Weaponized Against Moral Clarity
The report’s casualty figures – citing Hamas-run sources – obscure critical distinctions:
“Since then, more than 69,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli military action”
This passive construction deliberately avoids:
- Moral evaluation of Hamas’ use of human shields (condemned as intrinsically evil by Pius XII)
- Principle of jus in bello proportionality from traditional Just War doctrine
- Distinction between combatant and non-combatant deaths per Leo XIII’s Immortale Dei
By equating Israeli defensive actions with Hamas terrorism, the conciliar sect’s mouthpiece promotes moral equivalence – a heresy condemned by St. Robert Bellarmine: “No circumstance can justify cooperation with evil-doers against the common good of Christendom” (De Laicis, 1586).
False Ecumenism Undermines Evangelization Mandate
The diplomatic consultations between Egypt, Russia, and the US exemplify the condemned error of “separating the Church from the State” (Syllabus of Errors, Proposition 55). Vatican News celebrates these talks while suppressing the Church’s immutable teaching that “outside the Church there is no salvation” (Council of Florence, 1442).
Notably absent is any call for:
- Conversion of Muslims to Catholicism
- Restoration of Christian holy sites in Gaza
- Condemnation of Islamic persecution against Gaza’s remaining Christians
This silence constitutes apostasy from Christ’s Great Commission: “Going therefore, teach ye all nations” (Matthew 28:19). Pius XI warned that such peace initiatives “ignore the rights of God and His Christ” (Quas Primas), substituting human negotiation for divine order.
Antichrist System’s Pseudo-Peace Exposed
The resolution’s proposed “International Stabilization Force” fulfills Pius X’s prophecy in Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907) regarding modernist efforts to “substitute for the Church of Christ a worldwide humanitarian association.” By empowering the UN – an organization promoting abortion and gender ideology – as peace arbiter, the plan institutionalizes rebellion against Christ’s social kingship.
As St. Pius X decreed in Lamentabili Sane, such schemes manifest the modernists’ “denial of the Church as a perfect society established by Christ” (Proposition 56). True Catholics recognize this as preparation for the Antichrist’s false peace, which “will promise men liberation from every evil” while rejecting divine authority (St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, III Q.8).
Source:
U.N. Security Council to vote on Trump’s Gaza peace plan (vaticannews.va)
Date: 17.11.2025