Neo-Church’s Naturalism Masquerading as Charity in Sumatra Crisis
EWTN News reports on relief efforts by “Caritas Indonesia” following Sumatra floods that killed over 1,000 people, focusing on material aid distribution while perpetuating the conciliar sect’s ecological modernism. The December 24, 2025 article uncritically presents “Father” Fredy Rante Taruk and “Bishop” Antonius Subianto Bunjamin as legitimate Catholic authorities, despite their adherence to post-conciliar heresies. The text exemplifies how the Vatican II sect substitutes supernatural charity with secular humanitarianism, ignoring the primacy of the spiritual (Matthew 6:33) in favor of environmentalist narratives.
Sacramental Desert in the Midst of Material Assistance
The disaster response described epitomizes the neo-church’s abandonment of its divine mission: “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them…” (Matthew 28:19). While detailing distribution of “60 tons of humanitarian aid,” the report contains:
- Zero mentions of Masses offered for victims
- No reference to administration of Last Rites to the dying
- Absence of sacramentals distribution (holy water, blessed medals)
- Silence regarding calls to prayer or repentance
This reduction of the Church’s mission to mere social work constitutes apostasy from Pius XI’s teaching that “the Church contributes much more effectively to the establishment of peace and furthering of human happiness than by restoring the reign of Our Lord” (Quas Primas, 1925). The conciliar sect’s operatives distribute food while starving souls of grace – a betrayal more catastrophic than any flood.
Ecological Modernism Replaces Catholic Eschatology
“Father” Supriyadi Pardosi’s environmental activism exemplifies the conciliar revolution’s inversion of priorities:
“Care for creation is inseparable from care for human life. The degradation of nature is, in essence, the degradation of human life itself.”
This naturalistic heresy directly contradicts:
- The Syllabus of Errors’ condemnation of those who place “earthly happiness” above eternal salvation (Pius IX, 1864)
- St. Paul’s admonition: “Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things” (Colossians 3:2)
- The Church’s perennial teaching that temporal disasters serve as memento mori, calling sinners to repentance
When “Capuchins” lead political protests against corporations instead of preaching penance, they fulfill Pius X’s warning about Modernists who “pervert the eternal concept of truth” (Lamentabili Sane, 1907).
Illegitimate Structures Parodying Catholic Charity
The article’s uncritical presentation of “Caritas Indonesia” and “Jesuit Refugee Service” ignores these organizations’ doctrinal corruption:
| Organization | Heretical Nature | Pre-1958 Condemnation |
|---|---|---|
| Caritas Internationalis | Promotes religious indifferentism through interfaith projects | Condemned in Mortalium Animos (1928) |
| Jesuit Refugee Service | Advances liberation theology and immigration relativism | Contrary to Quas Primas’ social reign of Christ |
These neo-Masonic entities operate under the novus ordo ecclesiology that Pius IX anathematized: “The Church is not a true and perfect society, entirely free” (Syllabus of Errors, Proposition 19). Their material aid without spiritual sustenance constitutes what St. Vincent Ferrer termed “giving bread while withholding the Eucharist.”
Silence on Divine Judgment Amidst Natural Catastrophe
Nowhere does the report mention God’s righteous judgment manifested through natural disasters, despite Scripture’s clear teaching:
“I called for a drought on the land and the mountains, on the grain, the new wine, the oil, on whatever the ground brings forth, on men and livestock, and on all their labors.” (Haggai 1:11)
The conciliar operatives’ environmentalist narrative replaces:
- Supernatural causality with climate change pseudoscience
- Call to repentance with political activism
- Eternal perspective with temporal Band-Aid solutions
This deliberate omission constitutes what St. John Chrysostom condemned as “the shepherd fleeing while wolves devour the flock.”
Conciliar Sect’s Apostasy Manifest in Crisis Response
The Sumatra relief effort exposes the Vatican II sect’s complete abandonment of Catholic identity:
- Sacramental desertification: No mention of Eucharistic processions for divine mercy
- Ecumenical betrayal: JRS operates in “predominantly Muslim areas” without evangelization
- Naturalism: Reduction of the Church to NGO distributing material goods
- False ecclesiology: Treatment of post-conciliar structures as legitimate Church
As true Catholics mourn both the natural disaster and the spiritual catastrophe of conciliar apostasy, we recall Pius XI’s warning: “When God and Jesus Christ are removed from laws and states, the foundations of authority are destroyed” (Quas Primas). Until Indonesia submits to Christ the King through consecration to His Sacred Heart – not environmental activism – no lasting peace or protection can be expected.
Source:
Catholic Church responds to deadly Indonesia floods as leaders warn of environmental crisis (catholicnewsagency.com)
Date: 24.12.2025