The EWTN News portal (November 17, 2026) reports on the Napa Legal Institute’s 2026 “Faith and Freedom Index,” which ranks U.S. states by their adherence to the Masonic chimera of “religious freedom,” finding most scoring below fifty percent. Kansas (87%) and Alabama (94%) are hailed as models; Michigan (24%) is pilloried. The article treats Dignitatis Humanae‘s heresy as Catholic doctrine, celebrating secular legal frameworks that reduce the Church to a mere “faith-based nonprofit” begging for regulatory crumbs from the civil power. This is not a defense of the Church’s rights but a capitulation to the very laicism Pius XI condemned as “the plague that poisons human society.”
The Index Itself Is a Monument to the Heresy of Religious Liberty
The Napa Legal Institute’s index measures compliance with a concept solemnly condemned by the Syllabus of Errors: “In the present day it is no longer expedient that the Catholic religion should be held as the only religion of the State, to the exclusion of all other forms of worship” (Pius IX, Syllabus, Error 77). The article reports this ranking as if it were a Catholic duty to monitor how well secular governments grant “permissions” to the Church. Quas Primas teaches the exact opposite: “When God and Jesus Christ… were removed from laws and states and when authority was derived not from God but from men, the foundations of that authority were destroyed” (Pius XI, Quas Primas, 1925). The index does not measure the social reign of Christ the King; it measures the degree to which the civil power tolerates religious exercise as a private hobby. This is indifferentism quantified.
Linguistic Surrender: The Church Reduced to a “Faith-Based Nonprofit”
The article’s vocabulary betrays the total naturalization of the ecclesiastical concept. The Church is repeatedly called a “faith-based nonprofit” or “faith-based organization.” Frank DeVito, Napa senior counsel, speaks of “legal frameworks that allow religious organizations to focus on their mission rather than time and resource-consuming legal compliance requirements.” This is the language of a lobbyist, not a prince of the Church. The Syllabus condemns the error that “The Church is not a true and perfect society, entirely free… but it appertains to the civil power to define what are the rights of the Church” (Error 19). By adopting the state’s bureaucratic taxonomy — “Blaine amendments,” “Religious Freedom Restoration Acts,” “regulatory freedom” — the conciliar sect’s media arm implicitly accepts the civil power as the grantor of ecclesiastical liberty. Cum ex Apostolatus Officio and Canon 188.4 teach that jurisdiction comes from Christ, not from legislative grace.
Theological Bankruptcy: Blaine Amendments and the “Free Exercise” Trap
The article notes that even top-ranked Alabama retains a “Blaine amendment against religious education.” Historically, Blaine amendments were anti-Catholic measures to prevent public funding of “sectarian” (i.e., Catholic) schools. The index treats their retention as a mere demerit in a scorecard of “freedom.” But Quas Primas declares: “The state must leave the same freedom to the members of Orders and Congregations… who are indeed the most valiant helpers of the Pastors of the Church and contribute most to the expansion and establishment of Christ’s Kingdom.” The true Catholic principle is not “freedom from state interference” but the duty of the state to fund and favor the true religion. Pius IX condemned the proposition that “The Church ought to be separated from the State, and the State from the Church” (Syllabus, Error 55). The Napa index, and EWTN’s reporting on it, treats separationism as the baseline and “accommodation” as a victory. This is the Americanist heresy in its purest form, condemned by Leo XIII in Testem Benevolentiae (1899).
Symptomatic Level: The Conciliar Sect’s Media Arm as Propagandist for Dignitatis Humanae
Daniel Payne, identified as a “senior editor at Catholic News Agency,” produces this piece not as a critique of the index’s false premises but as a straight news report. The article concludes with a solicitation for EWTN newsletters — commercializing the very platform that disseminates this indifferentism. This is the modus operandi of the post-conciliar structure: it does not defend the rights of God (iura Dei); it negotiates the privileges of man. Lamentabili Sane Exitu condemned the modernist proposition that “The Church is incapable of effectively defending evangelical ethics, because it steadfastly adheres to its views, which cannot be reconciled with modern progress” (Error 63). The conciliar sect has “reconciled” itself by adopting the enemy’s framework. The index’s finding that “religious freedom scores do not neatly fall along partisan lines” is presented as insight; in reality, it proves that both wings of the American political spectrum are equally hostile to the Social Kingship of Christ, and the conciliar sect is comfortable in either camp.
The Michigan Anomaly: When the “Worst” State May Be the Most Honest
Michigan scores 24%, criticized for having “no state-level Religious Freedom Restoration Act and offers no protections for religious exercise during a state of emergency.” The article treats the absence of a RFRA as a defect. But a RFRA is a statutory admission that the state’s default posture is to burden religion unless a “compelling interest” test is met. It enshrines the principle that religious exercise is a privilege granted by the sovereign, not a right flowing from the Kingship of Christ. Michigan’s low score may simply reflect a more honest secularism: the state makes no pretense of “accommodating” the Church. The conciliar sect prefers the hypocrisy of Alabama (94% with a Blaine amendment) because it flatters the illusion that the civil power can be a partner. Quas Primas warns: “Let rulers of states therefore not refuse public veneration and obedience to the reigning Christ… if they wish to maintain their authority inviolate.” No index of “regulatory freedom” can substitute for this duty.
The “Regulatory Freedom” Distraction
The article notes a “regulatory freedom rundown, where most states score much higher than their respective results on the religious freedom index.” This reveals the fraud: the state is “free” for commerce but not for Christ. The conciliar sect celebrates the former while whining about the latter. Pius XI foresaw this: “Unbridled desires, often cloaked in the guise of public good and love of country, from which arises division among citizens and blind and immeasurable egoism.” The Napa Institute, EWTN, and CNA are part of this egoism — they seek a comfortable niche within the Masonic order rather than its conversion. The true index of a nation’s health is not its RFRA status but whether its laws confess Christus Rex. By that measure, every state on the list fails utterly, and the conciliar sect’s media apparatus fails with them by refusing to say so.
Conclusion: No “Victory” in the Devil’s Courtroom
Frank DeVito calls “Every good state law that helps rather than hinders the work of religious organizations… a victory.” This is the counsel of despair. The Church does not beg for “good state laws”; she demands the recognition of Christ’s rights. St. Pius X in Lamentabili condemned the proposition that “Truth changes with man, because it develops with him, in him, and through him” (Error 58). The truth of Christ’s Kingship does not change with Michigan’s score or Alabama’s amendment. The EWTN article is a bulletin from the abomination of desolation reporting on the terms of its own captivity. Non possumus. The only “index” that matters is the one written in the blood of the Martyrs: Jesus Christ is King of Kings and Lord of Lords (Apoc. 19:16). All else is vanitas vanitatum.
Source:
Majority of U.S. states continue to fail on religious freedom, says watchdog group (ewtnnews.com)
Date: 17.11.2026