Conciliar Sect Ordains Lawyer-Deacon: Naturalism Masquerading as Priesthood

EWTN News portal (November 20, 2026) reports the impending “ordination” of one Ernest “Ernie” Hart, a 67-year-old former New York Supreme Court justice, NYPD deputy commissioner, lawyer, and professor, to the “priesthood” in the diocese of Bridgeport by the “bishop” Frank J. Caggiano. The article details Hart’s extensive secular curriculum vitae—criminal court judge, associate dean at Columbia University, adjunct professor at CUNY—presenting his late-life vocation as an inspiring narrative of perseverance (“never too late”). It notes his prior marriage, divorce, and subsequent declaration of nullity, his 2011 “diaconal ordination,” and his current role as general counsel for the diocese, a position he will retain while assuming the “pastorate” of St. Anthony of Padua in Fairfield. The piece is a quintessential example of the conciliar sect’s reduction of the sacred priesthood to a managerial function for aging bureaucrats.


The Juridical Fiction of a Vocation Without Supernatural Root

The cited article relates the “call” Hart felt in second grade, yet frames its realization entirely through the lens of naturalistic achievement: “My experience as a lawyer benefits the diocese; it’s worked out well.” This is the hermeneutic of utility elevated to a vocational principle. Where is the sensus Ecclesiae? Where is the timor Domini? The article breathes not a word of the Sacerdos alter Christus, the victim-priest offering the Unbloody Sacrifice of Calvary for the propitiation of sins. Instead, we read of “general counsel,” “criminal justice,” “political science,” and the bureaucratic quip: “That’s the job of priests these days. They don’t have any free time.” This is not the language of the Cura Animarum; it is the jargon of the corporate boardroom. The Syllabus of Errors (Pius IX, 1864) condemned the proposition that “The civil government… has a right to an indirect negative power over religious affairs” (Error 41) and that “The best theory of civil society requires that popular schools… should be freed from all ecclesiastical authority” (Error 47). Here, the inverse is realized: the ecclesiastical office is emptied of its supernatural content and filled with civil jurisprudence. The “priest” becomes a functionary of the state in cassock.

Invalid Orders: The Forma of the New Rite and the Defect of Intention

From the perspective of integral Catholic faith, the “ordination” scheduled for November 21 is a nullity ab origine. The “bishop” Caggiano, consecrated in the post-1968 Pauline rite of episcopal consecration, lacks the potestas ordinis to confer the sacrament of Order. The 1968 Pontificale Romanum, promulgated by the antipope Paul VI, altered the essential forma of the sacrament, suppressing the traditional traditio instrumentorum and the explicit invocation of the Holy Ghost for the specific grade of priesthood (ut sacerdos fiat), replacing it with a vague “spiritual power” formula. As Pope Pius XII defined in Sacramentum Ordinis (1947), the matter and form must signify the specific sacramental grace. The new rite fails this dogmatic requirement ipso facto.

Furthermore, the candidate himself—formed entirely in the conciliar seminary system, imbued with the modernist theology of the “priesthood of the faithful” and the “presbyteral fraternity”—almost certainly lacks the intentio faciendum quod facit Ecclesia (the intention to do what the Church does). The Church, prior to 1958, teaches that the priesthood is a character indelebilis configuring the man to Christ the High Priest and Victim, for the offering of the Sacrificium propitiatorium. The article reveals Hart’s intention: administrative service (“general counsel”), social work (“officiated many weddings… baptisms”), and career fulfillment. This is a simulacrum of Orders, a theatrical performance devoid of sacramental reality. As the Defense of Sedevacantism file demonstrates regarding the automatic loss of office for heresy, the conciliar hierarchy, having defected from the Catholic Faith (Modernism, Religious Liberty, Ecumenism), possesses no jurisdiction and no power of Orders. Excommunicatus vitandus cannot confer what he does not possess. Nemo dat quod non habet.

The Divorce-Annullment Carousel: Juridicism Replacing Morality

The article casually mentions: “Hart was divorced and received a declaration of nullity from the Church before he could pursue the priesthood.” This reveals the rot at the core of the conciliar “annulment” industry. The pre-1958 Church, following the Council of Trent (Sess. XXIV, Can. 7), taught the absolute indissolubility of the marriage bond (matrimonium ratum et consummatum dissolvi non potest). The modern “declaration of nullity” has become a divortium catholicum, a juridical fiction manufactured by tribunals staffed by lawyers like Hart himself, to legitimize second unions and clear paths for “vocations” that reek of human respect and careerism. The fact that a former Supreme Court justice utilizes his own professional expertise to navigate the “canonical” bureaucracy to enter the “priesthood” is a scandal of Pharisaical proportions. It mocks the words of Christ: “What therefore God hath joined together, let no man put asunder” (Matt. 19:6). The Lamentabili Sane Exitu (1907) condemned the Modernist error that “The Church cannot, in any way, pass judgment on opinions concerning human abilities” (Prop. 5) and that “Faith… is ultimately based on a sum of probabilities” (Prop. 25). Here, the “sacrament” of Orders is treated as a career milestone achievable via legal probability and bureaucratic clearance.

Reduction of the Priesthood to Social Work: The Quas Primas Antithesis

Pope Pius XI, in Quas Primas (1925), thundered: “When God and Jesus Christ… were removed from laws and states and when authority was derived not from God but from men, the foundations of that authority were destroyed.” The article presents Hart as the embodiment of this removal. His “priesthood” is defined by his utility to the diocese as “general counsel,” his academic prestige, and his police connections. There is zero mention of the Missae Sacrificium, the Confessionale, the Extrema Unctio, the battle against the mundus, caro, et diabolus. The “pastorate” of St. Anthony’s is described as a job assignment. This is the laicism Pius XI identified as the “plague that poisons human society,” now fully internalized within the conciliar sect’s clergy. The “priest” is no longer alter Christus; he is a “community organizer” with a law degree. The Syllabus (Error 55) condemned: “The Church ought to be separated from the State, and the State from the Church.” The conciliar sect has achieved the synthesis: the Church is the State, and its “priests” are civil servants.

EWTN: The Propaganda Arm of the Novus Ordo Establishment

The source, EWTN News, functions as the Pravda of the conciliar sect. It sanitizes the apostasy, presenting a heartwarming human-interest story where a theological catastrophe occurs. The byline—Amira Abuzeid, “senior editor… with a special interest in bioethics, technology, theology, and religion in public life”—signals the secularized, NGO-style framework of this pseudo-apostolate. The “newsletter” signup at the end (“Daily/Weekly… I agree to receive communications from EWTN”) confirms the commercial, marketing-driven nature of the enterprise. They sell the “ordination” as a product: “Never too late.” The true Church does not market vocations; she forms saints through the Cross. EWTN, founded by the charismatic Mother Angelica (herself a product of the post-conciliar deviation), has consistently whitewashed the New Mass, the Assisi abominations, and the heresies of the conciliar “popes.” This article is another brick in the wall of the abomination of desolation standing in the holy place.

Symptomatic Level: The Novus Ordo Clergy as a Geriatric Bureaucracy

Hart’s age (67) and background are symptomatic of the demographic and spiritual collapse of the conciliar “priesthood.” Unable to attract young men with the supernatural ideal of the Mass and the Cross, the sect ordains retired judges, lawyers, and professors—men who have already lived their lives in the world, secured their pensions, and now seek a comfortable “second career” with status and housing. This is the clericalization of the laity and the laicization of the clergy prophesied by the Modernists condemned by St. Pius X in Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907). The “deacon” Hart served for 15 years (since 2011) in the “diaconate”—itself a novelty of Vatican II, restoring a “permanent” order unknown to the Tradition of the Latin Church for a millennium, designed precisely to clericalize married laymen. The step to “priesthood” after the wife’s death (implied by the timeline) is the standard operating procedure of the neo-church. It violates the immemorial discipline of the Church (Council of Trent, Sess. XXIII, Can. 9) which forbids the ordination of men who have been married twice (or whose wives are living, in the case of the East, though the West requires celibacy). The “declaration of nullity” is the juridical key that unlocks this violation.

The Silence of the Supernatural: The Gravest Accusation

Read the article again. Search for the words: Sacrifice, Sin, Hell, Grace, Soul, Salvation, Cross, Mass, Victim, Propitiation, Transubstantiation, Real Presence. They are absent. The “theology” of the piece is purely sociological: “serve his people,” “officiated weddings,” “baptisms,” “general counsel,” “criminal justice.” This is the cult of man denounced by Pius XI. The “bishop” Caggiano will lay hands on a man who views the priesthood as the capstone of a legal career. The faithful of Fairfield will receive not a father of souls, but a canon lawyer in vestments. Ichabod—the glory has departed. The diocese of Bridgeport, like every structure of the conciliar sect, is a synagoga Satanae (Apoc. 2:9), a paramasonic structure occupying the visible patrimony of the Church. The “ordination” is a Masonic ritual of the Church of the New Advent, sealing the usurpation of the hierarchical order. Non est inventus similis illis in terra (Job 1:8)—there is no likeness to the Catholic priesthood on this earth within these walls.

Conclusion: The “ordination” of Ernest Hart is a sacrilegious farce, a juridical fiction enacted by an invalid hierarchy within an apostate sect. It signifies the final triumph of the spiritus saeculi over the Spiritus Domini. No grace flows from the hands of “bishop” Caggiano; no sacrifice will be offered by “father” Hart. The faithful are warned: Fugite ex medio Babylonis (Jer. 51:6). The true Church, the Ecclesia Militans, endures only in the catacombs of Tradition, where the Mass of All Times is offered by valid priests holding the unchanging Faith, awaiting the restoration of all things in Christ the King.


Source:
Never too late: Deacon becomes priest at 67 after years as judge, lawyer, professor
  (ewtnnews.com)
Date: 20.11.2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Antichurch.org
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.