Virginia School Transgender Policy Lawsuit Reveals Conciliar Apostasy Roots
Catholic News Agency (December 5, 2025) reports a settlement between Fairfax County Public Schools and a Catholic student (“Jane Doe”) who sued over transgender policies requiring pronoun usage contrary to biological reality. The school district conceded nominal damages and attorney fees after allegedly violating the student’s constitutional rights. America First Legal declared this a “major victory” against “radical gender policies,” citing similar cases nationwide including California class actions and Ohio teacher settlements. The article notes contradictory studies on youth transgender identification rates while framing the lawsuit as part of broader resistance to school policies permitting males in female facilities.
Natural Law Subverted by Conciliar Revolution
The article’s celebration of legal technicalities obscures the radix malorum (root of evil): The conciliar sect’s abandonment of Quas Primas (Pius XI, 1925), which declared Christ’s Kingship over all civil institutions. Where Pius XI condemned secular governments that “refuse to submit to the rule of our Savior,” the neo-church fosters the very apostasy enabling transgender ideology. The student’s distress stems from the post-conciliar hierarchy’s failure to thunder:
“He who is not with me is against me” (Matthew 12:30).
Pius IX’s Syllabus of Errors (1864) explicitly condemned the notion that “the State… can contain within itself and administer the whole of the moral virtues” (Proposition #39). Yet the lawsuit reduces Catholic resistance to bathroom access disputes rather than condemning state-enforced heresy against God’s created order.
Linguistic Cowardice Masks Heretical Foundations
The article employs modernist terminology – “transgender policies,” “gender ideology” – which implicitly accepts the heretical premise that “gender” exists apart from biological sex. Contrast this with Pius X’s condemnation in Lamentabili Sane (1907) of those who reduce Revelation to “man’s self-awareness of his relationship to God” (Proposition #20). The student’s self-censorship mirrors the conciliar sect’s own silence on:
- The ontological impossibility of “changing sex” (Genesis 1:27)
- The mortal sin of scandal through pronoun usage (Matthew 18:6)
- The eternal consequences of promoting sexual confusion (1 Corinthians 6:9-10)
Bureaucratic “Victories” Versus Supernatural Combat
America First Legal’s triumph rings hollow when the conciliar sect’s USCCB continues funding politicians who enact transgender laws. The $500,000 teacher settlements pale against the blood of martyrs who died rather than burn incense to Caesar. Where St. Thomas More declared:
“I die the king’s good servant, but God’s first”
modern “conservatives” negotiate bathroom privileges while accepting the state’s blasphemous redefinition of human nature. The article’s reference to “private restrooms” as accommodation epitomizes the conciliar mentality – reducing holiness to comfort rather than demanding societal conversion.
Omissions That Condemn
The report ignores how this persecution flows directly from Vatican II’s Dignitatis Humanae, which granted false religions equal dignity with Christ’s Church. When the conciliar sect embraced religious liberty, it empowered states to impose transgender dogmas as civil religion. Missing are quotes from:
- Leo XIII’s Immortale Dei (1885): “States cannot… be governed without any reference to the divine and eternal law”
- Pius IX’s Quanta Cura (1864): Condemning “that false and absurd maxim… that liberty of conscience and worship is each man’s personal right”
Symptomatic of Total Apostasy
This lawsuit exemplifies how the conciliar sect reduced Catholicism to a lifestyle choice within secular pluralism. Where pre-1958 popes commanded Catholic rulers to suppress heresy (Pius IX, Syllabus #77-80), neo-church “victories” beg secular courts for bathroom partitions. The student’s ordeal proves the conciliar sect’s impotence against evil it helped unleash through:
- Abandoning the Social Kingship of Christ
- Embracing religious indifferentism
- Redefining marriage at Vatican II (Gaudium et Spes)
Until Catholics recognize the conciliar sect as apostate and return to true pre-1958 doctrine, such legalistic crumbs will only delay divine judgment on our Sodomite age.
Source:
Virginia school district concedes lawsuit by Catholic student over transgender policies (catholicnewsagency.com)
Date: 05.12.2025