EWTN’s ‘Geniuses Believe in God’: Scientism Masquerading as Apologetics in the Conciliar Sect

The EWTN News portal reports on the presentation in Madrid of the book Genios creen en Dios (“Geniuses Believe in God”) by José Carlos González-Hurtado, president of EWTN Spain. The work compiles 23 biographies of scientists across various disciplines who allegedly professed faith or converted, intending to demolish “the myth that science contradicts God.” The event featured praise for figures like Allan Sandage, Werner Heisenberg, Alexis Carrel, and Francis Collins, the latter appointed to the “Pontifical Academy of Sciences” by “Pope” Benedict XVI. González-Hurtado defined faith using St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas but concluded that unbelief stems primarily from a defective will (“atheism is normally a malady rooted in the will”). He announced future volumes arguing for the Catholic Church’s uniqueness and the Virgin Mary’s existence. This enterprise epitomizes the conciliar sect’s naturalistic apologetics, reducing the supernatural virtue of faith to a rationalistic choice and legitimizing the usurping hierarchy in the Vatican.


Factual Deconstruction: The Conciliar Sect’s Propaganda Apparatus

The article originates from EWTN News, the media arm of the Eternal Word Television Network, founded by Mother Angelica under the aegis of the post-conciliar hierarchy. This network functions as a primary instrument of the novus ordo establishment, ceaselessly promoting the false legitimacy of the claimants to the Holy See since John XXIII. The “president of EWTN Spain,” González-Hurtado, is a lay functionary within this paramasonic structure; his “books” are commercial products marketed to a demographic desperate for intellectual validation within the collapsing neo-church.

The “scientists” paraded as witnesses are tellingly ecumenical: Werner Heisenberg (Lutheran), Francis Collins (Protestant, former atheist, head of the Human Genome Project), Alexis Carrel (a eugenicist and Vichy collaborator whose late-life “return” was to a vague theism, not the Catholic Faith). Even Allan Sandage is cited for deciding “to live as if God existed until he found him” – a pragmatic wager, not the act of faith infused by God. The inclusion of Collins, appointed by the antipope Ratzinger to the “Pontifical Academy of Sciences,” exposes the false ecumenism inherent in the conciliar project: unity of faith is replaced by unity of scientific prestige.

Linguistic Analysis: The Rhetoric of Naturalism and Pelagianism

The language betrays a thoroughly naturalistic mindset. The author speaks of “dispelling myths,” “prominent figures,” “noteworthy or even amusing episodes,” and “growing interest in religious matters within certain circles.” This is the vocabulary of marketing and sociology, not theology. Faith is treated as a lifestyle choice validated by celebrity endorsement.

The most egregious linguistic corruption is the definition of faith’s motive. González-Hurtado cites St. Thomas: “an act of the intellect under command of the will assisted by grace,” but immediately truncates the supernatural element: “to possess faith, you must first think; second, will to believe; and third, God must will it,” concluding that “the reason most people who don’t have faith is because they don’t want to.” This is semi-Pelagianism pure and simple. It makes the primary cause of faith the human will’s preparation, reducing grace to a mere accessory (“God must will it” as a third step). The Council of Trent anathematizes this: “If anyone says that man can be justified before God by his own works… without the grace of God through Jesus Christ, let him be anathema” (Sess. VI, Can. 1). The phrase “atheism is normally a malady rooted in the will” pathologizes unbelief as a psychological defect, ignoring the obscuritas intellectus and the malitia voluntatis consequent upon original sin, which only gratia sanans can heal.

Theological Level: Scientism, False Ecumenism, and the Denial of the Supernatural Order

The book’s premise – “Geniuses Believe in God” – commits the category error of scientism: it uses the authority of natural science (the “geniuses”) to validate the supernatural. This inverts the proper order: gratia non tollit naturam, sed perficit (grace does not destroy nature but perfects it), but nature cannot judge grace. The motives of credibility (miracles, prophecy) are subordinate to the motive of faith (the authority of God revealing). By making scientific eminence the criterion, the author makes human reason the measure of divine truth – the very definition of Modernism condemned by St. Pius X in Pascendi Dominici Gregis: “The Modernist… makes human reason the ultimate standard of truth” (Prop. 3, Lamentabili Sane Exitu).

The reference to “Pope Benedict XVI” appointing Collins manifests the heresy of recognition: treating the usurper Ratzinger as a true Vicar of Christ. As St. Robert Bellarmine teaches (De Romano Pontifice, II, 30), a manifest heretic ipso facto loses the papacy. The conciliar “pontiffs” from John XXIII onward have publicly professed heresies (religious liberty, false ecumenism, collegiality, the new mass), and thus cannot be true popes. To cite their acts as authoritative is to participate in the great apostasy foretold in 2 Thessalonians 2:3.

The promised future volumes – “reasons why the Catholic Church is the only true Church” and “evidence regarding the existence of the Virgin Mary” – will inevitably be written from within the conciliar paradigm, identifying the “Catholic Church” with the neo-church occupying the Vatican. This is the great deception: using orthodox terminology to legitimize a counterfeit institution. As Pius XI taught in Quas Primas: “Peace is only possible in the kingdom of Christ” – not in the kingdom of the “scientific genius” or the “dialogue” of the neo-church.

Symptomatic Level: The Neo-Church’s Survival Strategy

This book launch is a symptom of the conciliar sect’s terminal crisis. Having abandoned the Traditional Latin Mass, the Catechism of Trent, and the Syllabus of Errors, the neo-church must manufacture relevance through apologetics of accommodation. It apes the world’s methods: celebrity culture, scientific prestige, publishing deals, media events. The proceeds “benefit EWTN Spain” – mammona iniquitatis (Luke 16:9) sustaining the structure of the abomination of desolation (Matt. 24:15).

The silence is deafening: no mention of the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the Sacraments, the state of grace, the Four Last Things, the Social Kingship of Christ, or the vacancy of the Holy See. This silence is the gravest accusation. It proves the enterprise is purely naturalistic, a opus humanum devoid of virtus infusa. The “conversions” celebrated (baptisms, “joining the Catholic Church from other traditions”) are entries into the counter-church, not the Ecclesia Catholica subsisting in the remnant faithful to Tradition.

St. Pius X condemned the Modernist method: “They make the religious sense the foundation of faith… they attribute to it a certain divine character… thus they make faith a kind of sentiment” (Pascendi, §4). González-Hurtado’s “think, will, God wills” is exactly this: faith as human project. The true Catholic apologist does not parade Nobel laureates; he preaches Christ crucified, unto the Jews a stumbling-block, and unto the Gentiles foolishness (1 Cor. 1:23), knowing that non est in alio aliquo salus (Acts 4:12) – and that this salvation is found only in the Una, Sancta, Catholica et Apostolica Ecclesia which today endures only where the Traditio is kept inviolate, sine macula et ruga (Eph. 5:27), outside the structures of the Great Apostasy.


Source:
‘Geniuses Believe in God’ is latest book by EWTN Spain president
  (ewtnnews.com)
Date: 17.11.2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Antichurch.org
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.