Conciliar Sect Ordains Worldly Judge as ‘Priest’: Naturalism Masquerading as Vocation

The National Catholic Register, mouthpiece of the conciliar sect, reports that one Ernest “Ernie” Hart, a 67-year-old former New York Supreme Court justice, NYPD deputy commissioner, lawyer, and professor, will be “ordained a priest” on November 21, 2026, by the “Bishop” of Bridgeport, Frank Caggiano. The article presents this event as a heartwarming “late vocation,” emphasizing Hart’s secular accolades, his divorced-and-annulled status, his role as diocesan general counsel, and his children’s amusement at calling him “Father Father Hart.” The piece is a masterclass in naturalistic hagiography, utterly devoid of the supernatural, celebrating a functionary of the neo-church who embodies the conciliar revolution’s reduction of the priesthood to a social-service career for retired bureaucrats.


The Farce of “Valid Orders” in the Conciliar Rite

From the perspective of integral Catholic faith, the entire spectacle is a sacrilegious simulation. The “ordination” will employ the Novus Ordo rite of Paul VI (1968), which defects in form and intention for the Sacrament of Holy Order. As Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre — himself doubtfully ordained by the Freemason Liénart — admitted, the new rite suppresses the essential words defining the priest’s potestas consecrandi and potestas absolvend, replacing them with a vague “presidential” function. Even if Caggiano possessed valid episcopal orders — which is morally impossible given the universal adoption of the invalid 1968 rite and the heretical intention of the conciliar “bishops” — the ceremony confers no sacramental character. Hart will remain a layman, albeit one invested with a juridical fiction by a schismatic sect.

The Defense of Sedevacantism file establishes that a manifest heretic loses office ipso facto (Canon 188.4, 1917 Code). Caggiano, as a “bishop” of the post-conciliar hierarchy, professes the heresies of Vatican II: religious liberty, ecumenism, collegiality, and the new ecclesiology. He is therefore not a bishop but a usurper. Cum ex Apostolatus Officio (Pope Paul IV) declares the promotion of a heretic null, void, and of no effect. Hart’s “ordination” is thus a nullity squared: invalid matter (a non-bishop) and invalid form (the 1968 rite).

Linguistic Level: The Vocabulary of Naturalism

The article’s language exposes its anti-supernatural essence. Nowhere does one find the terms sacerdos, victima, propitiatory sacrifice, character indelebilis, gratia sacramentalis. Instead, we read: “general counsel,” “pastor of St. Anthony,” “criminal justice,” “political science,” “employee and labor relations,” “free time,” “explore it,” “regrets,” “supportive children.” The priesthood is reduced to a career pivot, a “job” for which a law degree “benefits the diocese.” Hart’s quip — “That’s the job of priests these days. They don’t have any free time” — encapsulates the functionalist, bureaucratic mentality of the neo-church. The Syllabus of Errors (Pius IX) condemns the proposition: “The Church is not a true and perfect society… but it appertains to the civil power to define what are the rights of the Church” (Error 19). Here, the “Church” is a civil corporation, its “priests” are legal counselors, and its “vocations” are HR decisions.

Theological Level: The Married “Priest” and the Annulment Factory

Hart is a divorced father of three who received a “declaration of nullity” — the conciliar sect’s divorce-à-la-carte — to pursue the “priesthood.” This violates the immutable discipline of the Church: Canon 1041 (1917) imposes irregularity on those with a living spouse; Canon 1042 on those who have contracted a second marriage. The “annulment” racket, institutionalized by the neo-church, makes a mockery of Matrimonium ratum et consummatum non potest dissolvi (Council of Trent, Sess. 24, Can. 7). The article treats this canonical fiction as a routine administrative step: “Hart was divorced and received a declaration of nullity from the Church before he could pursue the priesthood.” No mention of the indissolubilitas of the bond, no mention of the sacramental character of marriage. This is the fruit of Modernism condemned in Lamentabili Sane Exitu (Prop. 59): “The dogmas of faith should be understood according to their practical function, i.e., as binding in action, rather than as principles of belief.” The “annulment” is a pragmatic tool to staff the neo-church’s “parishes.”

Symptomatic Level: The Clericalization of the Laity and the Laicization of the Clergy

Hart’s biography — judge, police commissioner, professor, dean, general counsel — reads like a résumé for a corporate executive, not a curriculum vitae for an alter Christus. The article boasts of his “many responsibilities” and notes he will retain his post as general counsel after “ordination.” This is the clericalization of the laity and laicization of the clergy prophesied by St. Pius X in Pascendi Dominici Gregis: the priest becomes a “social animator,” a “community organizer,” a functionary of the secular city. The Quas Primas encyclical (Pius XI) declares: “His reign encompasses also all non-Christians, so that most truly the entire human race is subject to the authority of Jesus Christ.” The neo-church, by contrast, subjects Christ to the authority of the secular state. Hart served the New York Supreme Court and the NYPD — the very civil powers that the Syllabus condemns for claiming “a certain right not circumscribed by any limits” (Error 39). Now he brings that statist mentality into the sanctuary.

The Racial Narrative as Ideological Weapon

The article injects a gratuitous racial grievance: Hart’s mother “thought the Church was racist”; his grandmother founded St. Peter Claver Church because “Black people weren’t welcome in the church across the street.” This is liberation theology rhetoric, the hermeneutic of suspicion applied to the Church’s history. It serves the conciliar sect’s agenda: to portray the pre-conciliar Church as structurally sinful and the post-conciliar sect as the agent of “justice.” Pius XI in Quas Primas warns: “When God and Jesus Christ were removed from laws and states… the foundations of that authority were destroyed.” The injection of identity politics into a “vocation story” proves the neo-church’s primary allegiance is to the world, not to Christ the King.

The “Deacon” Factory and the Destruction of the Minor Orders

Hart was “ordained a deacon in 2011.” The Novus Ordo “permanent diaconate” for married men is a novelty unknown to Tradition, instituted by Paul VI in Sacrum Diaconatus Ordinem (1967) contrary to the Canons of Trent (Sess. 23, Can. 4) which anathematize those who deny the hierarchy of orders. The suppression of the minor orders and subdiaconate by Paul VI (1972) destroyed the cursus honorum by which a man was tested in castitas, obedientia, paupertas before approaching the altar. Hart bypasses all this: a worldly potentate made “deacon” at 52, “priest” at 67, never having lived a day of vita canonica or vita religiosa. This is the democratization of the priesthood condemned by Pius XII in Mediator Dei: “The priest acts for the people only inasmuch as he represents Jesus Christ.” Hart represents only the conciliar bureaucracy.

EWTN and the National Catholic Register: Propaganda Arms of the Neo-Church

The article originates from EWTN News / National Catholic Register, the media flagship of the “conservative” wing of the conciliar sect. Its function is to normalize the abnormality, to present the neo-church’s simulated sacraments and married “clergy” as business as usual. The “Keywords: priestly vocations” tag is a cruel irony: the neo-church’s “vocations” are a demographic catastrophe precisely because they offer no supernatural ideal, only a career path for retired judges. The true crisis of vocations is the absence of the true Mass and the true priesthood, driven from the visible structures by the abomination of desolation (Matt. 24:15).

Conclusion: Non est hic Deus

The “ordination” of Ernest Hart is a liturgical theater piece performed by a sect that has lost the Faith. It signifies nothing, effects nothing, and saves no one. The true Church of Christ — una, sancta, catholica, apostolica — subsists in those bishops and priests who retain the unchanging doctrine, the traditional Mass, and the valid sacraments, rejecting the conciliar errors and the usurpers in Rome. “He who gives the Kingdom of Heaven does not take away earthly things” (Pius XI, Quas Primas, citing the hymn Crudelis Herodes). The neo-church gives away earthly things — titles, pensions, diocesan counsel positions — because it has no Kingdom of Heaven to give. Ichabod: the glory has departed (1 Sam. 4:21).


Source:
Never Too Late: Deacon Becomes Priest at 67 After Years As Judge, Lawyer, Professor
  (ncregister.com)
Date: 20.11.2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Antichurch.org
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.