St. Francis’ Nativity Scene: Traditional Piety Versus Modern Distortions
Catholic News Agency portal (December 21, 2025) recounts St. Francis of Assisi’s creation of the first Nativity scene in Greccio, Italy in 1223. The article describes how Francis “desired to ‘re-present the birth of that Child in Bethlehem'” after being inspired by his Holy Land pilgrimage, with Lord Giovanni Velita preparing a cave with live animals and manger. It claims eyewitnesses saw “a real infant appear in the empty manger” during Mass, followed by miraculous healings through contact with the hay. The piece notes antipope Bergoglio’s 2019 visit to Greccio where he signed Admirabile Signum, emphasizing how “all who were present” experienced “new and indescribable joy” at Francis’ Nativity. The article concludes by mentioning annual reenactments at Greccio now in their 50th year. This sentimentalized narrative masks profound theological dangers beneath its pious veneer.








