Simcha Fisher’s False Optimism: The Heresy of Natural Happiness Without Grace
The Pillar portal publishes a paid column by Simcha Fisher (May 29, 2026) in which the author confesses her pessimistic temperament but claims to possess a “bedrock belief that everything is going to turn out okay” — a conviction she attributes not to supernatural faith, not to the theological virtues infused at baptism, not to the promises of Our Lord Jesus Christ, but to **the music of Johann Sebastian Bach**. This is the reduction of Christian hope to a purely natural, aesthetic sentiment — a Pelagian optimism divorced from grace, sacraments, and the supernatural order. It is, in miniature, the entire modernist project: replacing the theological virtue of hope with human feeling, and substituting the Creator with the creature.






