Loreto Legend: Naturalism Masquerading as Piety in Modernist Narrative
The Catholic News Agency portal (December 10, 2025) uncritically promotes the Loreto shrine through modernist lenses, treating the Holy House’s authenticity as an archaeological puzzle rather than a supernatural mystery. The article breathlessly recounts how “historic documents have vindicated the beliefs of pious pilgrims over the centuries — with an ironic twist,” reducing the angelic translation tradition to a naturalistic transfer by the Angeli family. This materialist presentation betrays the creeping naturalism infecting even “conservative” neo-church outlets.









